Every NBA Star is Linked to the Knicks. None of Them Actually Come.

In another chapter to a story that is endless, Shams Charania reported that Bucks superstar Giannis Antetokounmpo is “ready for a new home” at the trade deadline. That latest report prolongs a “will he, won’t” story that has followed Antetokounmpo for the last few years.

The reports of his perceived desire to be traded and subsequent verbal commitments to the Bucks have been ongoing, and quite frankly, exhausting. The Knicks, as they always seem to be, are at the center of these rumors dating back to this past off-season. The saga of Giannis is a highlight of rumor fatigue in the NBA ecosystem, but no fan base feels it more acutely than those in New York.

New York Magnification

Whenever there is a player that might be unhappy, inevitably there are rumors that link him to the Knicks. This is not a recent development either, it’s always been the case. There were stories decades ago about the Knicks in the mix to acquire players like Kareem Abdul Jabbar, Julius Erving, and Michael Jordan.

The appeal from a story perspective is easy enough to understand. New York City is the biggest market in the league. The Knicks play in an iconic arena, and the team has been chasing a return to the mountaintop for over half a century. Whenever there has been a big free agent this century the rumors about the Knicks have inevitably followed.

LeBron James, Dwyane Wade, Kevin Durant, Kyrie Irving, and Donovan Mitchell were all linked in rumors to the Knicks at one point or another. Giannis is simply the latest huge name star that the NBA rumor mill has inserted into preferring a move to the Knicks.

The issue is that every player loves to play at Madison Square Garden. New Orleans Pelicans star Zion Williamson once said that it’s “every players dream to play at Madison Square Garden”. Michael Jordan also loved playing at the Garden during his career noting that “It’s the Mecca of basketball. You always want to perform at your highest level when you play in the Garden.” The reverence by players comes because New York City as a whole loves the game of basketball, and its fans appreciate greatness when it’s in their presence—which matters to NBA players. That is a quality that still matters, and playing at the Garden, as a result, is often seen as a huge perk of being a Knick.

These days, players are brands in their own right. And while in the age of social media, a brand can be built from anywhere, there is still an added benefit to doing it in New York. As a hub of modern business, New York City often lures players to invest in companies and real estate in the city. Therefore, dots are connected regarding disgruntled stars preferring playing for the Knicks. There is proof of this in recent years. Julius Randle secured a deal with Skechers and JD Sports while he was a Knick, and Josh Hart has turned his scrappy role on the current team into multiple brand deals. There is a proximity to deals by playing in New York and that is yet another reason why the market is viewed as a target for potential star players.

From a fan perspective, this is a bit of a double-edged sword. On one hand, there is inherent excitement that comes from the fantasy of an All-NBA player joining your favorite team. But when it is inevitably just a smoke screen for another team to make a move, that comes with disappointment. Consider this cycle. Your team is mediocre and doesn’t seem to be contending for a title. Then a rumor suggests a disgruntled star prefers your team, so you get excited. The rumors swirl and reports come and go, only for that star player to end up with another team. This is the cycle that the Knicks seem to experience with every star player “sweepstakes”.

In that regard, when the team is linked to everyone, they are linked to no one. There is a reason this happens. The fanbase is rabid and has been starving for a title for multiple generations at this point. The modern content machine powered by social media fuels the conversation but has become saturated to the point of fatigue in the modern landscape.

Content Machine Fatigue

There is a lot of NBA content out there these days. There are countless podcasts, websites, rumor accounts, and YouTube channels. All are vying for the attention of the masses, and the best way to capture it is often through clickbait. The Knicks are an ideal clickbait or interest generator because they have a global brand with incredibly engaged fans—this dynamic plays out on social media daily.

Because social media algorithms often reward divisiveness and anger, posts that link just about anyone to the Knicks get traction. Since the fan base is so large and varied, these rumors often lead to debates weighing the merits of being aggressive versus standing pat, and what players should be spared in any mock trades.

That interest and outrage bait is magnified by aggregator accounts that take an offhanded quote on a podcast and turn it into the topic of the day. With so much content available today through various distribution channels, accounts like Legion Hoops and NBA Central have endless ways to generate engagement with followers. The issue is that many of these quotes are taken out of context of a longer conversation—with an express intention of causing anger and conversation to drive more views to the aggregator’s content.

This has been the cycle with Giannis, and the insertion and interest of the Knicks has magnified it beyond other trade rumors that have involved the team in the past. In truth, it resembles the same sort of back and forth that was present before Carmelo Anthony was eventually traded to the Knicks. The process went on and on, and for many when it finally happened it was more of a relief that it got done more than anything.

This all creates some fatigue, a sense of wondering when this will happen. There is an incessant need to hope that the next report is accurate, and with such a short news cycle, the regurgitation of essentially the same report quickly turns into monotony. It forces the question of whether it is all a sort of song and dance or will a player eventually be traded?

With all of the ways of retrieving basketball news these days, there is a certain numbness that comes with, yet another report or rumor as opposed to the substantial breaking of something that has occurred.

Veering From the Norm

The interesting thing about all the Giannis to the Knicks noise is that when Leon Rose had acted and made a trade it was often with less notable fanfare. The trade for Karl-Anthony Towns was a bit of surprise, as many expected the team to trade for a stopgap center as opposed to a superstar player. The deals that brought in Mikal Bridges and OG Anunoby were to be expected but also had less fanfare.

These are the moves that have defined the Knicks front office in the Leon Rose era. Moves that made basketball sense and weren’t fodder for the NBA rumor mill ecosystem. The signing of Jalen Brunson was mostly expected but was undercut by the rumors of trading for Donovan Mitchell. This group has always avoided a sort of splashy move for the sake of making a splashy move.

While the Knicks were linked to Brunson for a long stretch of time due to his father, Rick, being on the coaching staff, his potential acquisition paled in comparison to the potential trade for Donovan Mitchell. Understandably, that was because Mitchell was an established superstar while Brunson was an unknown commodity. That entire off-season was dominated by the game of chess being played between Danny Ainge (President of Basketball Operations of the Utah Jazz) and Leon Rose, with so many wondering how the Knicks would get the deal done. Even after the signing of Brunson was imminent, Mitchell still dominated the conversation—an indication of rumors rising to the top more than anything else in today’s landscape.

That is what makes all this Giannis chatter feel a bit more like the vaporware rumors of the past, especially when considering the lack of a convincing package that the Knicks can offer at the deadline. All indications are that the Bucks covet young foundational players or draft picks, and the Knicks have neither of those things.

If a deal were to happen, it would be in the summer when they have more access to future draft capital. But that doesn’t fit into the exciting concept of a deal being done within a week that has stakes in this season. Giannis trade rumor fatigue is going into overdrive this week. Every podcast in the NBA world is talking about it, and the Knicks are often brought up first.

It feels like a road that has been travelled before and is something that may net nothing other than false hope and time wasted on the NBA Trade Machine. Trade rumors have become the lifeblood of modern NBA content, and the idea of a shakeup in a roster is incredibly intoxicating, so it is repeated endlessly. The Knicks specifically attract headlines no matter what they do or (more importantly) do not do—and perhaps that is the most tiring thing of all in this process.

Thanks for reading Deep Cover! This post is public so feel free to share it.